By Heather L. Lawton
As suspicious as it may appear, not every young woman sitting on an older man’s lap in the industry is inappropriate. But when a woman is married to a man with accusations of sexual assault who has admitted to being unfaithful many times, we need to refocus and start calling out legitimate, demeaning relationships between men and women.
In the case of Beyoncé and producer Marc Schaffel, there is no evidence of past abuse by him, and we see nothing of that nature in the video. So a bright-eyed woman of consenting age sitting on an older man’s lap can seem benign and pale in comparison to her later choices. Beyoncé and Schaffel’s cheeky behavior should be the least of the internet’s worries. The man she later married should be scrutinized. The singer and Jay-Z were married in 2008, and the rapper has told multiple outlets that he has grappled with infidelity.
The Daily Mail recently released footage of a 19-year-old Beyoncé sitting on a Schaffel’s lap while waiting on a call from Michael Jackson. Surprisingly, I part with most of the online critics and their alarm over the video I saw. I wasn’t uncomfortable in the slightest. Perhaps, I have become so desensitized to men’s bullet-point(and proof) system of predatory behavior, it has distorted my judgement. Instead, I am vexed by the Beyoncé and Jay-Z problem.
Seeing the 2001 photo of Beyoncé on Marc Schaffel’s lap was a mild adaptation of Lolita, a watered-down copy of Christian and Anastasia (50 Shades of Grey), and nowhere near rendering R. Kelly and Aaliyah (Kelly’s backup dancer stated he began abusing Aaliyah between the ages of 13 and 14). It’s Beyoncé and Jay-Z’s relationship, mirroring spines on a cactus, scraping against the norms of healthy relationships, normalizing and on the verge of glamorizing male philandering that is problematic.
If netizens want to channel their outrage supporting Beyonce, it should be toward her choice of husband. Let us always remember that Jay-Z proudly told a New York Times reporter that he cheated on Beyoncé many times ( I heard him say he was unfaithful 15 years out of their then 17-year relationship, but the video is no longer in circulation).
